The housing crisis for older women

Retirement can seem a pretty abstract idea to a young woman in the workforce. I have to admit that until recently I’ve been rather optimistic about my “older” years, naively presuming I will live in my own home, using my hard-earned superannuation to fund a comfortable life.

Living in poverty is not part of my golden plan, but when you consider that unprecedented numbers of older, single women are experiencing a housing crisis, my vision for the future is rose-coloured to say the least.

While there are different pathways to homelessness for older women, such as inter-generational poverty or a history of ongoing housing disruption, what we are currently witnessing is a cohort of “conventional” women who are experiencing a housing crisis later in life.

These are women we all know: they have been in the workforce, raised families and contributed to their communities as volunteers. Despite being part of a generation who have benefitted from the right to work, they are in a financially vulnerable position.

The gender pay gap means women not only take home less pay than their male counterparts, they accrue less superannuation and savings. We can expect to earn about $700,000 less over a lifetime than men, and retire with half as much superannuation. If a woman takes extended time out of the workforce to have children, she has even less financial stability.

And, as Project Coordinator for Equality Rights Alliance (ERA) Hannah Gissane explains, it can take just one trigger for a woman to find herself in a very precarious housing situation.

‘That’s the thing for a lot of older women, it could be a job loss, it could be a relationship breakdown, illness or acquiring a disability,’ she says.

‘These are the sort of shocks in life that we should be able to weather but because these women are financially on the precipice, it can spell homelessness or really severe housing stress.’

In their joint 2015 submission to the Senate Standing Committee, ERA and Homelessness Australia reported an estimated 600, 830 women over the age of 45 were on low-median incomes and not in outright home ownership.

‘So you’ve got these issues of poverty, issues of superannuation gaps, and rates of divorce mean that often women are retiring without home ownership and they’re going into private rental later in life,’ Hannah says.

The private rental market in Australia, as many of us are well aware, is expensive. While share-houses are an option for younger generations, many homes simply do not cater for the needs of our older, aging women.

‘There’s a real lack of action from governments to boost affordable housing supply and so you’re stuck in this limbo land of a private rental market that just doesn’t cater for your needs,’ Hannah says.

‘It’s harder to find accessible housing, it’s harder to find housing that meets your needs, it’s harder to find it well located and affordable and you’ll get stuck on the public housing waiting list for up to ten years in so many places.

‘Our safety nets are just not adequate.’

The safety nets available are almost non-existent. Knowing who to turn to for help in the first place is a major obstacle for older women, as many have never had to navigate services such as Centrelink or government housing.

It can be daunting to reach out, and even if they do seek assistance, the help they receive is usually limited. The demand for public housing in each state far outweighs what is available and homelessness services often just don’t cater for older women.

‘A lot of homelessness services do things tailored around life skills and getting a job. They’re tailored to younger men often and to really different experiences of homelessness, whereas for these women, they just need somewhere to live and the rest of it they can do,’ says Hannah.

‘So I think a homelessness service that is tailored for older women would be focussed on community, on bringing women together on addressing social isolation and on getting women back into affordable housing.

‘The longer women are in that situation of homelessness or prolonged housing stress or insecurity, the worse it becomes – but if you can do this rapid transition back into housing they can handle the rest.’

With a severe lack of infrastructure and support services, Australia is now seeing the creation of what social activist Penny Leemhuis calls “OWLs” – Older Women Lost to housing.

It’s a situation Penny deals with personally on a daily basis. After acquiring a disability in her 30s, she was classified as totally and permanently incapacitated and unable to work.

‘I did get a payment but that went towards modifying my car, bathroom, kitchen and all those essential things so I could actually function on a day to day basis,’ she says.

‘So that cut off my access to superannuation, in combination with the fact that I had basically stayed at home and contributed to my community like many other women of my generation by being the canteen mum, the sports mum, the family daycare mum, with very low wages and no superannuation.’

An inequitable settlement following a relationship breakdown eleven years ago, coupled with Penny’s inability to obtain full-time work, led her to crisis point.

She has moved almost ten times, including interstate from Victoria to Canberra, in an attempt to find affordable housing that is also accessible, and leaves her with enough money to pay for food and car expenses.

Penny currently lives in Queanbeyan, New South Wales. While the rent is kept at a minimum, there are 16 concrete steps at both the front and back of the house to navigate. Despite daily challenges, Penny maintains a sense of humour and leads a busy life.

In 2014, she founded the Older Women Lost in housing website, which provides information for other older women experiencing housing crisis. Since its launch, it has received over 800,000 visitors.

In her work as an affordable housing advocate, she is championing for equitable and systemic change for women in Australia, regularly presenting at forums and conferences on the issues facing older women.

‘There are a number of reforms that I think we really need to look at,’ she says.

‘We need a campaign that educates the population about the issues facing these women, the causes of these issues, and preventative measures. I don’t think it needs to be just an ad on TV or radio, it needs to go into schools and it needs to be across both genders.

‘What I found after a recent event where I gave a speech to students was interestingly, the young men had been going to their dads (and telling them about the speech). One of the dads, a CEO, said “Who is this bloody woman? My son keeps going on about we need equality, how much are you paying the women, what about their super?” and I was like “Yes!” because that’s what we need to target.

‘I’m very preventative and solution driven – I can see a cause, but you can’t just put a bandaid on it and say we’ll build more affordable housing, it needs to run much deeper than that.’

One solution to the current housing crisis, Penny says, would be to offer sustainable and needs-appropriate options such as independent co-housing and shared land equity.

YWCA Canberra has demonstrated this kind of model works with Lady Heydon House. Each of the five women living at Lady Heydon has her own bedroom, sitting room, ensuite and kitchenette, and shares a larger kitchen, dining room and two living spaces.

With more than 600,000 women facing housing crisis, clearly more funding is needed to boost the number of affordable housing projects.

‘We’re at a stage in our advocacy where we’re showcasing these example of organisations responding to the needs of older women in a way that caters to their experiences, so that’s YWCA Canberra’s Lady Heydon House in Canberra, and Women’s Property Initiatives in Melbourne,’ says Hannah.

‘The thing that’s lacking there is scale, so we want to go to government and say we’ve got the model, but it’s the scale, it’s the funding, it’s the political will and attention that’s missing.’

Penny agrees that political inaction is a key factor in the housing crisis, but says we need to work as a community to drive change.

‘We all need to get on board – the developers, the builders, financial gurus – because they’re all driving the track of housing that then puts people into poverty,’ she says.

As she poignantly points out: ‘If we don’t address this now, what kind of future will there be for women of your generation and your daughters?’

Image: Andre Robillard

__

MA PhotoMelissa Archer is a freelance writer and journalist living in Brisbane. She has written for publications including Brisbane News, The Courier-Mail, The Sunday Mail, Peppermint Magazine, and Lip. 

Melissa blogs over at Art & Soul and you can read more of her work here

 

3 Comments

  • Penny Leemhuis commented on February 20, 2016 Reply

    Thank you Melissa for taking the initiative to raise awareness of the housing crisis facing O.W.’s (Older Women Lost to housing).

    This is a critical issue as secure, affordable appropriate housig is the basis from which all othe life flourishes from.

    Your article highlighted the evidence based inequities that women of this generation & future generations face regarding housing security.

    Particularly your article was presented in a respectful and factual way. While driving home the ultimate consequence of lack of housing as the most disadvantage people can experience – that of poverty.

    Thank you once again for your commitment to taking the older women and homelessness issue out of it’s hidden space and into the public arena.

    Kind regards
    Penny

  • AMD commented on March 2, 2016 Reply

    Thank you for bringing this to light. I am a 60 year old woman who ran her own business. However, long story, but having been ripped off by someone I am now facing bankruptcy. As I was divorced years ago most of my wage went on raising children and I was unable to reenter the housing market. If it were not for a housing organisation who assisted me to find housing I would have been out on the street. I was unable to continue to rent privately and they found me emergency housing for myself and my animals.

    It truly is a much neglected area and as I am no longer able to work due to health reasons I am in no position to reenter the private market. It’s not only governments who are ignoring this issue. Telling people of a similar age my situation, I have been humiliated, scorned, blamed and admonished for not having had a man to support me for the past 20 years. Had I not been ripped off financially, I would have survived and even been able to look after myself in old age. It’s not always a matter of not planning as sometimes life gets in the way.

  • Angharad W. commented on March 19, 2016 Reply

    I was a mortgage-paying “homeowner” for decades. I’m certain that I speak for many older women in detailing my plight. I never managed to pay off my home loan due to becoming redundant at 49 and never finding another job as opposed to casual part-time positions, despite having a uni education and a professional qualification. My super was far less than my spouse’s because I took time off work to have a baby and because every time he moved to another location for the sake of his career I upped and went too. My circumstances altered drastically and now I find myself renting in the tight unregulated private rental market, where I can be given just 60 days notice to vacate. It’s insufficient notice.. As time goes on I dread the “notice to vacate” more than ever. It’s not easy finding an affordable place and packing up in that time period, plus paying two rents (one for the remaining time in the current place and one to secure the new) and paying a bond in order to secure a new rental is virtually inevitable, putting a strain on finances during the changeover period. As a renter I can’t have a pet, and I can’t make alterations to the property to make it more older person-friendly. I do without handles in the bath and by the front door, things that I would install if I had my own home. As a renter I’m not secure in my suburb and I feel alienated as I lack a stake in Australia and because some (not all) landlords and agents think I’m a lesser being because I’m a renter. Also, I fear that the older I get the less attractive I’ll seem as a tenant. Meanwhile, the government imports more and more immigrants and encourages foreign buyers, permits empty untenanted investment properties, while Australians can’t get on the property ladder. Cruel and insane.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.